13 Haziran 2013 Perşembe

An All-Harvard CEA

With the news that Betsey Stevenson is joining the CEA, the three-member board will now have two Harvard PhDs and a Harvard professor. Just saying....

Update: A friend points out, "Actually, we have had an all-Harvard CEA for some time since Betsey is replacing Katharine Abraham (a Harvard Ph.D.) and Jason is replacing Alan Krueger (a Harvard Ph.D.)."

Euro zone: the common cycle is strong

The general thinking is that if you want to create a monetary union, a strong prerequisite is that the business cycles in the involved economies should be well synchronized, among other criteria. The reason is obvious: it allows consensus regarding monetary policy. This synchronization may arise after the merger, though, facilitated by the currency area.

Periklis Gogas looks at the Euro-zone and comes to the conclusion that synchronization has increased, especially with the last global recession. While the paper has plenty of robustness exercises, I fail to be convinced, though. Indeed, this supposed trend is based on two, maximum three, business cycles. And the last recession was of a different kind, being global, so it is difficult to avoid having it more synchronized than any other in the sample. You may argue that there are 86 quarterly observations and this is sufficient for statistical significance. But when you look at such questions, it is turning points that matter, and you only have a handful, and they do not look like a random sample of the population.

12 Haziran 2013 Çarşamba

Where did the gender unemployment gap go?

There was a time where females had little attachment to the labor force, and employers also considered them to be the easiest to dispense with in the case of a downturn. These lead to a gender unemployment gap, with females proportionally more unemployed. Times have changed. Females are now in many households the main breadwinners and thus more attached to the labor market than men, even during recessions. This has manifested itself in full force during the last one, which has been dubbed a "mancession" by some because the unemployment rate rose more for men than for women. That was new, and needs an explanation.

Stefania Albanesi and Ayşegül Şahin use a three-state labor search model to understand the data in various OECD countries. They confirm that the change in relative labor attachment explains the disappearance of the long-run gender unemployment gap. At business cycle frequencies, and in particular during recessions, the key is in the sectoral distribution of the female and male workforce. And as this distribution evolves, females benefit from more employment stability than men. Is this last recession a breakpoint for the labor market? There are so many things that are different from before, like super-low employment rates, hysteresis, and declining labor income shares. This all points to structural changes, and we should forget getting back to pre-recession labor markets.

Come to Where the Energy Is: Myanmar Country

With apologies to the Philip Morris Co.'s iconic figure, let's draw some analogies here: Both Marlboro and Myanmar are not exactly the most politically correct of figures, one representing the hazards of cigarette smoking and the other decades of political oppression. That said, both are irresistible draws in certain, undeniable respects. Marlboro is instantly recognizable worldwide for its cowboy, go-it-alone romantic imagery of the "American West." Myanmar, meanwhile, epitomizes the exoticism of the "Far East" to many Westerners. Despite their less-than-perfect reputations, they remain top-drawer economic attractions. Marlboro remains a Top 20 global brand, while Mynamar's considerable natural resources will always have its takers. [Photo c/o Process Design Engineering blog.]

So it is with the recent normalization of Myanmar's relations with the rest of the world (best illustrated by it hosting a World Economic Forum event) that it's sought energy sector investment from MNCs whose countries previously barred them from doing business with the military junta. It's like a land grab out there as its "frozen in time" oil and gas fields are going to be up for auction soon. And, unlike the oil and gas fields of Southeast Asian neighbours the Philippines and Vietnam, China is not disputing ownership over them. (Call it an accident of geography since China has this habit of claiming everything within, alas, striking distance.) Indeed, prior to the recent wave of liberalization, China was next to the only foreign investor of note in Myanmar after India. But anyway, back to the story...
[Australia's] Roc, [France's] Total SA (FP), [Italy's] Eni SpA (ENI) and [India's] Oil & Natural Gas Corp. are among 59 companies that qualified earlier this year to bid for onshore fields in Myanmar, according to the nation’s energy ministry. Myanmar is also offering 30 offshore blocks. Myanmar’s potential gas resources are estimated at as much as 45 trillion cubic feet, Roc said in February, citing a U.S. Geological Survey report. Myanmar has 7.8 trillion cubic feet of proven gas reserves, according to BP Plc data.“That’s quite a significant prize, and clearly the industry feels that as well given the appetite,” Eliet said. 
Due to having fewer geopolitical tussles with China alone, Myanmar's prospects for energy recovery may be said to be better than those of the Philippines and Vietnam irrespective of their reserves. It's certainly indicative of the lure of the "resource curse" that a country such as Myanmar stands to fill its coffers so much just by practicing rudimentary improvements in governance, but I guess that shows you how fierce competition is worldwide for fossil fuels even at this time when energy costs have receded somewhat.

11 Haziran 2013 Salı

Mortgage refinancing is not that hard

We continuously take economic decisions. Most of the time, they are trivial. Sometimes they are important, and any sensible person thinks hard before settling on an option. Purchasing a home is complex, for example. Can one afford it? Is it the right price? How will it evolve? How is the financing? Comparatively, refinancing a mortgage is relatively easy: what is the interest saving? What are the fix costs? How long does one expect to hold this mortgage?

Yet, it appears a substantial fraction of those refinancing their home mortgage make lightheaded mistakes, according to Sumit Agarwal, Richard J. Rosen and Vincent Yao. Using a dataset that covers homeowners who only refinance to reduce mortgage payments, they find that 52% pick the wrong interest rate (off by at least 50 basis points) and 17% wait at least six months too long, likely because they do not monitor rates. That could be excused by inattention, but when you consider the amounts involved, they would need to have some very lucrative alternative uses of their time. That is quite disappointing for those who model optimizing agents.

10 Haziran 2013 Pazartesi

Biased taxable income elasticities

Anytime you apply a distortionary tax, it bring well-being losses from the distortion (although the revenue can be used for well-being enhancing public goods). In addition, there are social losses that arise from the fact that people try to evade the tax by shift to other goods, go informal, or in the case of income shift compensation to non-taxable benefits or other amenities like more flexible work hours. Traditionally, the literature has evaluated the deadweight loss from taxation by looking at the income elasticity of the tax. That may be too simple a statistic in this case.

Brendan Epstein and Ryan Nunn show that ignoring the endogeneity of the non-taxed benefits and amenities leads to serious biases in the income elasticity and thus deadweight loss, to the point that it provide not good guidance on how to set tax rates. They basically do this by providing examples: build simple models, calibrate them, generate data from them and show that the usual empirical method provide crassly wrong estimates. An econometrician could in principle do better by taking all this in account, unfortunately data will be very hard to come by for this.

The Jason Furman Fan Club

AEI Chapter.

Update: Here the President's announcement of Jason's appointment.

13 Haziran 2013 Perşembe

An All-Harvard CEA

With the news that Betsey Stevenson is joining the CEA, the three-member board will now have two Harvard PhDs and a Harvard professor. Just saying....

Update: A friend points out, "Actually, we have had an all-Harvard CEA for some time since Betsey is replacing Katharine Abraham (a Harvard Ph.D.) and Jason is replacing Alan Krueger (a Harvard Ph.D.)."

Euro zone: the common cycle is strong

The general thinking is that if you want to create a monetary union, a strong prerequisite is that the business cycles in the involved economies should be well synchronized, among other criteria. The reason is obvious: it allows consensus regarding monetary policy. This synchronization may arise after the merger, though, facilitated by the currency area.

Periklis Gogas looks at the Euro-zone and comes to the conclusion that synchronization has increased, especially with the last global recession. While the paper has plenty of robustness exercises, I fail to be convinced, though. Indeed, this supposed trend is based on two, maximum three, business cycles. And the last recession was of a different kind, being global, so it is difficult to avoid having it more synchronized than any other in the sample. You may argue that there are 86 quarterly observations and this is sufficient for statistical significance. But when you look at such questions, it is turning points that matter, and you only have a handful, and they do not look like a random sample of the population.

12 Haziran 2013 Çarşamba

Where did the gender unemployment gap go?

There was a time where females had little attachment to the labor force, and employers also considered them to be the easiest to dispense with in the case of a downturn. These lead to a gender unemployment gap, with females proportionally more unemployed. Times have changed. Females are now in many households the main breadwinners and thus more attached to the labor market than men, even during recessions. This has manifested itself in full force during the last one, which has been dubbed a "mancession" by some because the unemployment rate rose more for men than for women. That was new, and needs an explanation.

Stefania Albanesi and Ayşegül Şahin use a three-state labor search model to understand the data in various OECD countries. They confirm that the change in relative labor attachment explains the disappearance of the long-run gender unemployment gap. At business cycle frequencies, and in particular during recessions, the key is in the sectoral distribution of the female and male workforce. And as this distribution evolves, females benefit from more employment stability than men. Is this last recession a breakpoint for the labor market? There are so many things that are different from before, like super-low employment rates, hysteresis, and declining labor income shares. This all points to structural changes, and we should forget getting back to pre-recession labor markets.

Come to Where the Energy Is: Myanmar Country

With apologies to the Philip Morris Co.'s iconic figure, let's draw some analogies here: Both Marlboro and Myanmar are not exactly the most politically correct of figures, one representing the hazards of cigarette smoking and the other decades of political oppression. That said, both are irresistible draws in certain, undeniable respects. Marlboro is instantly recognizable worldwide for its cowboy, go-it-alone romantic imagery of the "American West." Myanmar, meanwhile, epitomizes the exoticism of the "Far East" to many Westerners. Despite their less-than-perfect reputations, they remain top-drawer economic attractions. Marlboro remains a Top 20 global brand, while Mynamar's considerable natural resources will always have its takers. [Photo c/o Process Design Engineering blog.]

So it is with the recent normalization of Myanmar's relations with the rest of the world (best illustrated by it hosting a World Economic Forum event) that it's sought energy sector investment from MNCs whose countries previously barred them from doing business with the military junta. It's like a land grab out there as its "frozen in time" oil and gas fields are going to be up for auction soon. And, unlike the oil and gas fields of Southeast Asian neighbours the Philippines and Vietnam, China is not disputing ownership over them. (Call it an accident of geography since China has this habit of claiming everything within, alas, striking distance.) Indeed, prior to the recent wave of liberalization, China was next to the only foreign investor of note in Myanmar after India. But anyway, back to the story...
[Australia's] Roc, [France's] Total SA (FP), [Italy's] Eni SpA (ENI) and [India's] Oil & Natural Gas Corp. are among 59 companies that qualified earlier this year to bid for onshore fields in Myanmar, according to the nation’s energy ministry. Myanmar is also offering 30 offshore blocks. Myanmar’s potential gas resources are estimated at as much as 45 trillion cubic feet, Roc said in February, citing a U.S. Geological Survey report. Myanmar has 7.8 trillion cubic feet of proven gas reserves, according to BP Plc data.“That’s quite a significant prize, and clearly the industry feels that as well given the appetite,” Eliet said. 
Due to having fewer geopolitical tussles with China alone, Myanmar's prospects for energy recovery may be said to be better than those of the Philippines and Vietnam irrespective of their reserves. It's certainly indicative of the lure of the "resource curse" that a country such as Myanmar stands to fill its coffers so much just by practicing rudimentary improvements in governance, but I guess that shows you how fierce competition is worldwide for fossil fuels even at this time when energy costs have receded somewhat.

11 Haziran 2013 Salı

Mortgage refinancing is not that hard

We continuously take economic decisions. Most of the time, they are trivial. Sometimes they are important, and any sensible person thinks hard before settling on an option. Purchasing a home is complex, for example. Can one afford it? Is it the right price? How will it evolve? How is the financing? Comparatively, refinancing a mortgage is relatively easy: what is the interest saving? What are the fix costs? How long does one expect to hold this mortgage?

Yet, it appears a substantial fraction of those refinancing their home mortgage make lightheaded mistakes, according to Sumit Agarwal, Richard J. Rosen and Vincent Yao. Using a dataset that covers homeowners who only refinance to reduce mortgage payments, they find that 52% pick the wrong interest rate (off by at least 50 basis points) and 17% wait at least six months too long, likely because they do not monitor rates. That could be excused by inattention, but when you consider the amounts involved, they would need to have some very lucrative alternative uses of their time. That is quite disappointing for those who model optimizing agents.

10 Haziran 2013 Pazartesi

Biased taxable income elasticities

Anytime you apply a distortionary tax, it bring well-being losses from the distortion (although the revenue can be used for well-being enhancing public goods). In addition, there are social losses that arise from the fact that people try to evade the tax by shift to other goods, go informal, or in the case of income shift compensation to non-taxable benefits or other amenities like more flexible work hours. Traditionally, the literature has evaluated the deadweight loss from taxation by looking at the income elasticity of the tax. That may be too simple a statistic in this case.

Brendan Epstein and Ryan Nunn show that ignoring the endogeneity of the non-taxed benefits and amenities leads to serious biases in the income elasticity and thus deadweight loss, to the point that it provide not good guidance on how to set tax rates. They basically do this by providing examples: build simple models, calibrate them, generate data from them and show that the usual empirical method provide crassly wrong estimates. An econometrician could in principle do better by taking all this in account, unfortunately data will be very hard to come by for this.

The Jason Furman Fan Club

AEI Chapter.

Update: Here the President's announcement of Jason's appointment.